However, even though not pressing, the House of Lords does still require reformation, and if not now, then when? The chamber is populated mostly by 92 hereditary peers, 26 Lords Spiritual and a large number of political appointees. Many of the hereditary peers were cleared out some years ago by the Blair government..It would be very hard to assert that the 786 peers who currently make up the House of Lords are a representative sample of the UK population. A majority of the lords passed middle age quite a few summers ago. There are too few (181) women, too few black and Asian people, and too few people with disabilities. I am happy to support reform of the House of Lords.
The popular solution to the objection that the House is unrepresentative is to suggest that membership should be by popular election - either 80% or 100% of members being elected. However, I see little value in replicating the process of electing members of the House of Commons. Instead, my preference would be for an all-appointed House, made up of every facet of British life. So there would be representatives from:
- trades unions (TUC)
- the employer's federation (CBI)
- BBC radio
- commercial radio
- BBC television
- commercial television
- the film industry
- the live music and recorded music industries
- the theatre
- the visual arts
- the Consumers' Association
- the construction industry
- the road transport industry
- the rail industry
- the airline industry
- the airports
- the sea ports
- the coast guard
- the police
- the fire and rescue service
- the ambulance service
- the British Army
- the Royal Navy
- the Royal Air Force
- military intelligence
- the Anglican Church
- the Roman Catholic Church (this might require a change in Canon Law)
- the Greek Orthodox Church
- the Methodist Church
- Jehovah's Witnesseses
- the Salvation Army
- the Baptist Church
- the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers)
- the Unitarian Church
- the Humanist Association
- an Orthodox Jew
- a Reformed Jew
- a Sunni Muslim
- a Shia Muslim
- a Hindu
- a Jain
- a Buddhist
- a pagan
- every significant ethnic group in the country, including Roma people;
- Russell Group universities
- Million + universities
- FE colleges
- sixth form colleges
- secondary schools
- primary schools
- teachers' unions
- headteachers
- hospitals
- the British Medical Association
- nurses and midwives
- dentists
- chiropodists;
- social work
- probation
- prison service
- the charitable sector
- volunteer organisations
- the National Trust
- animal protection organisations
- conservation organisations (such as CPRE)
- political parties across the political spectrum, including the far right and far left
- London
- English Midlands
- North East England
- North West England
- South East England
- South West England
- Southern England
- Northern Ireland
- Highland Scotland
- Lowland Scotland
- Wales
- the EU
- the US
- the BRIC countries
- the Commonwealth
- young people
- pensioners
What would the reformed House be called? How about the House of Representatives?
1 comment:
Interesting view.
Post a Comment